Scrutinel— 2026 midterms

UpdatedOct 10, 2026, 11:27 AM EDT
To election day24 days
Simulations200,000

Idaho 2nd District

Currently held by a Republican · incumbent running

Democrat
Elinor Gilbreath
1%
Republican
Mike Simpson
99%
ForecastSafe R
Projected margin
R+22.5
80% range
R+34.0 to R+11.0
Partisan lean
R+26.3
Uncertainty multiplier
1.80×

The 80% range comes from 200,000 simulations in which this race’s error is correlated with every other race through the national, state and demographic layers.

How the estimate is built
Fundamentals >99.9%
Polling average
no polls
Fundamentals
R+22.3
Blended
R+22.3
Similar-race shift
+2.0
Polling

No public polling of this matchup. The forecast rests on fundamentals plus the polling residuals of demographically and politically similar races — which is the normal case: most of the 435 House seats are never polled.

Fundamentals
Partisan lean
R+26.3
Elasticity
0.97
Incumbency
−3.4
Candidate experience
0.0
Fundraising
−2.7
National environment
D+7.1
Expected margin
R+24.4
How it voted for presidenttwo-party
2024 margin
R+27.6
2020 margin
R+23.7
Shift 2020 → 2024
R+3.8
Votes cast, 2024
422,665

Presidential results reaggregated onto the 2026 district lines. This is where the seat’s partisan lean comes from, and it carries most of the forecast in a race nobody has polled.

Who lives hereCensus ACS
Population
684,272
Median age
46.6
Median household income
$68,800
Bachelor’s degree or higher
32%
White
80%
Black
1%
Hispanic
12%
Asian
3%

Used to find demographically similar districts, so a race with no polling can borrow the polling error of races that look like it.

Campaign fundraisingFEC filings to Invalid Date
CandidatePartyRaisedCash on hand
Michael SimpsonREP$1.1M$429k
Elinor GilbreathDEM$107k$71k

Receipts across the cycle, from FEC bulk filings. The model uses the ratio between the two sides rather than either total, and weights it lightly — money follows a competitive race at least as much as it causes one.

← Back to the full forecast